INFT 821 Paper Review Form
OO and Architecture-based Testing

Syllabus Papers Review Form Students Jeff's Home Page Paul's Home Page

Please fill out this form for each of the remaining papers in the class. The information will be mailed to the instructor. If this is one of the papers that you are providing a summary for, you can put your summary into the Summary box. Otherwise, please enter a one sentence description of the major results of the paper.

Paper:

Reviewer name:
Reviewer's competence in the topic: Marginal General Strong Expert
Is this one of your long summaries? Yes No

Technical strength of paper: Excellent Good Fair Poor
Novelty and significance of ideas: Excellent Good Fair Poor
Quality of presentation: Excellent Good Fair Poor
Overall Recommendation Strong Accept Weak Accept Weak Reject Strong Reject


Rationale for summary evaluation:

One sentence description of the paper's major results:

Summary of the paper:

This form uses 821ReviewForm.cgi ...